China Hurries to Burn More Coal, Putting Climate Goals at Risk

LINFEN, China — Desperate to meet its electricity needs, China is opening up new coal production exceeding what all of Western Europe mines in a year, at a tremendous cost to the global effort to fight climate change.

The campaign has unleashed a flurry of activity in China’s coal country. Idled mines are restarting. Cottage-sized yellow backhoes are clearing and widening roads past terraced cornfields. Long columns of bright red freight trucks are converging on the region to haul the extra cargo.

China’s push will carry a high cost. Burning coal, already the world’s single biggest cause of human-driven climate change, will increase China’s emissions and toxic air pollution. It will endanger the lives of coal miners. And it could impose a long-term cost on the Chinese economy, even while helping short-term growth.

World leaders are gathering next week in Glasgow to discuss ways to halt climate change. But China’s extra coal by itself would increase humanity’s output of planet-warming carbon dioxide by a full percentage point, said Jan Ivar Korsbakken, a senior researcher at the Center for International Climate and Environmental Research in Oslo.

“The timing is horrible, coming right before the climate summit,” he said. “Let’s hope it’s just a temporary measure to mitigate the current energy crisis.”

Beijing’s leaders are determined to provide ample coal this winter to power China’s factories and heat its homes. Widespread electricity shortages, caused partly by coal shortages, nearly paralyzed many industrial cities three weeks ago.

Cong Yanping checking his truck, which was loaded with coal, before driving from Shanxi Province, in China’s interior, to coastal Shandong Province.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

China is expanding mines to produce 220 million metric tons a year of extra coal, a nearly 6 percent rise from last year. China already digs up and burns more coal than the rest of the world combined.

The effort is infused with patriotism. “Guarantee the supply” has become a national slogan, appearing frequently now in state media and official statements and even on red banners on the front of coal trucks.

If the campaign succeeds, China will generate enough electricity not only for its own people but also for the hundreds of global companies in China that churn out everything from consumer electronics to car parts. Business leaders say that electricity shortages have already mostly abated in the past few days. Coal shipments have risen, utilities are generating more power, electricity-guzzling steel mills have cut output and mild weather has limited residential use.

The potential costs, on the other hand, go beyond global-warming emissions.

Rapid expansion means extra risks for the country’s 2.6 million coal miners. China’s National Mine Safety Administration said on Oct. 21 that 10 accidents had left 18 workers dead in the preceding four weeks, mostly in coal mines.

Some mining companies still suffer from “weak safety development concepts, inadequate learning from accidents, inadequate investigation and management of potential safety risks, and weak basic safety management,” the administration said.

A train platform loaded with coal in Shanxi, as coal shipments have risen in the country to help counter the power shortages.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

China has made huge strides toward cleaner air over the past decade, but extra coal use could threaten some of that progress. As recently as 2015, air pollution was found to contribute to 1.6 million premature deaths per year. The Chinese government warned on Monday that air pollution had risen in big cities in recent days but did not specify a cause.

The heart of the industry is China’s Appalachia, Shanxi Province, 300 miles southwest of Beijing. It is a region of steep, often terraced hills and valleys where coal has been mined for 2,100 years.

The province mined nearly a billion metric tons of coal last year. That was only about a quarter of China’s overall production, but still twice as much as the United States or Australia.

As in the United States and elsewhere, residents of coal-mining areas in China often support the industry and welcome extra output.

“The work is very important to me to make a living,” said Wan Husheng, a semiretired coal worker in Nanyaotou village, near the end of a long, narrow valley where small flocks of sheep grazed in fields already brown and wilted with autumn. “Coal is crucial.”

Truck drivers have converged on Shanxi as mines ramp up production and as utilities try to restock.

A worker removing mud from a coal mine facility in Shanxi that had flooded earlier this month.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

Cong Yanping showed up with his red truck from coastal Shandong Province and expected a slow, three-day drive home with a full cargo. “Most of the time, I usually live in the truck,” he said. “I take whatever order I get.”

Environmental and safety decisions played a key role in recent electricity shortages.

China has closed 5,500 coal mines, half of the country’s total, over the past five years. The rusting hulks of abandoned mines now litter mountain valleys in western Shanxi, the long diagonals of their conveyor belts sitting silent in wind and rain.

Older, smaller, more polluting and more dangerous mines, most privately owned, were closed. State-owned enterprises were allowed to build or expand more modern mines, but with less total capacity than the shuttered mines.

Then stringent new legislation took effect on March 1. Mine managers who dig more coal than their government-approved capacity faced potentially long jail sentences.

Many privately owned mines had previously overproduced coal to make extra profits. They frequently crowded more miners at subterranean coal seams than safety regulations allowed.

Smokestacks at an industrial park. Burning coal, already the world’s single biggest cause of human-driven climate change, will increase China’s emissions and toxic air pollution.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

State-owned enterprises that now dominate Chinese coal mining have long been cautious about overproducing. Since March, they have become even more skittish.

“Now that it’s a criminal charge, an executive especially at a state-owned enterprise has no incentive to commit this offense,” said Kevin Tu, a Beijing energy consultant and former China program manager at the International Energy Agency in Paris.

The closing of small mines and a national safety campaign have made coal mining much less dangerous. China lost 1,973 miners as recently as 2011. Last year, the death toll was 228.

The mine safety agency has authorized only 153 large, mostly state-owned mines to expand in coming months. Numerous small mines remained closed in west-central or southwestern Shanxi last week.

“The small coal mines have been shut down,” said Qi Zhiping, a 68-year-old maintenance worker at the Longze coal processing facility, which has been quiet for the last several years. “The state-owned coal mines have standards.”

Coal shortages were not China’s only electricity problem by September. A lack of rain in southwestern China meant hydroelectric dams generated less power. Calm skies in northeastern China meant wind turbines also contributed less.

A damaged house in Pingyao, Shanxi, after heavy rains, which have hindered coal production in the region.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

Coal prices nearly doubled. Utilities, prevented from raising prices, began running power plants less. Blackouts followed as China’s factories ran flat out to meet strong demand. Heavy rains and flooding in Shanxi in early October briefly delayed China’s initial ability to dig extra coal. The Shanxi government said on Thursday that all but four mines have reopened.

Officials have responded by partially deregulating electricity tariffs. Depending on the province, energy-intensive industries like steel or chemicals production now face cost increases of as much as 50 percent. That may prompt them to embrace energy efficiency, said Yan Qin, a lead analyst at Refinitiv, a data provider.

Coal mine expansions usually take decades to cover their investment cost. But the country’s state-controlled utility sector has already pledged not to build any more coal-fired power plants after 2025.

Xi Jinping, China’s top leader, personally pledged last year that the country’s emissions of greenhouse gases would peak by 2030.

China has released few details of how it will meet that target. Jin Liqun, a former vice minister of finance who is now the president of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank in Beijing, said in an interview that the increase in coal mining was only a temporary response to what had been a rapid Chinese imposition of curbs on fossil fuels.

“The coal production at this stage is a correction of an overshoot,” he said. “It is not a long-term trend.”

For now, coal miners in Shanxi say that the sound of working mines means more money for them and their communities.

“The workers are digging black gold,” said Liang Lijian, a coal washing worker at the Huipodi coal complex in Liujiayuan, in southwestern Shanxi. “As soon as the machine runs, tens of thousands of taels of gold are made.”

Wan Husheng, a semi-retired coal worker, on a road overlooking a coal mine in Shanxi. Residents of coal-mining areas in China often support the industry and welcome extra output.Credit…Gilles Sabrié for The New York Times

Li You contributed research.

Back to top button